Monday, 16 November 2026Issue of 15 November

Science

Giant Crane Grus primigenia, Long Thought Extinct, Turns Out to Be a Larger Version of a Living Bird

For more than a century, scientists believed the giant crane vanished after the Ice Age. Ancient DNA analysis has shown that was a mistake: the bird never died out, and its smaller relatives still live in Europe today.

Giant Crane Grus primigenia, Long Thought Extinct, Turns Out to Be a Larger Version of a Living Bird
Photo: Daily Galaxy

The mystery of the giant crane began in the 19th century, when unusually large crane bones were discovered in caves in southern France. Their size led researchers to conclude that the remains belonged to a distinct prehistoric species, later named Grus primigenia. That view endured for a century and a half, because scientists had no genetic data with which to challenge it.

A new study from Bournemouth University upends that picture. The bird, it turns out, never went extinct. It was simply a larger form of the common crane, Grus grus, which can still be found in Europe today.

A 150-Year-Old Puzzle

The first to study the large crane bones, in the 19th century, was the French biologist Alphonse Milne-Edwards. Convinced that they belonged to a bird distinct from modern European cranes, he assigned them to a new species. Because the remains dated to the end of the last Ice Age, the bird was thought to have disappeared thousands of years ago.

To put those conclusions to the test, a team led by John Stewart, a professor of evolutionary palaeoecology at Bournemouth University, turned to ancient DNA analysis. The scientists examined 18 crane bones found in England, Wales, France, Germany and the Balearic Islands. The genetic material was analyzed in collaboration with the Center for Palaeogenetics in Stockholm. The results, published in the journal Royal Society Open Science, were unequivocal: the bones belonged to common cranes, not to a separate extinct species.

As Stewart explained, earlier studies had relied solely on the size and shape of the bones. DNA analysis made it possible to identify the species more precisely.

Why Scientists Got It Wrong

The confusion may have stemmed from the difference in size between males and females. Male common cranes are typically larger than females, and in Professor Stewart's view, this may have contributed to the original error. "We suspected that these large cranes had not gone extinct but were simply larger members of the modern European common crane," he said.

Yet the DNA results leave another question unanswered: Why were prehistoric common cranes so much larger than some of their modern relatives? The researchers suggest it may be linked to changes in the birds' habitat, in particular the loss of wetlands and shifts in land use. According to Stewart, the draining of marshes and new farming practices may have led cranes to become smaller. There are no firm conclusions yet, and the team plans to continue investigating these hypotheses.

Could Other "Extinct" Birds Have Survived?

Many ancient bird species were classified largely on the basis of the size and shape of fossil bones. But as this study shows, a larger skeleton does not always mean a different species. Some birds long considered extinct may simply have been larger or smaller variants of species that still exist. Professor Stewart noted that the number of birds that went extinct in the distant past may have been overestimated.

While many bird species today are genuinely vulnerable because of human activity, we may have overestimated the number of extinctions in the past. Some of them may simply have been changes in the size of species that are still alive.

— John Stewart, professor at Bournemouth University

These findings do not change the fact that many birds are under threat today. But they do show how ancient DNA analysis can overturn scientific views that had been accepted as true for more than a century. In the case of Grus primigenia, the story took an unexpected turn: the giant bird thought to have vanished along with the Ice Age turned out not to be a lost species at all.

Letters

You sign in with Telegram, and it takes a few seconds.

Laptops and tech on the Union board

395,957ads posted on the Union board

Browse ads

More from Union Post