Monday, 16 November 2026Issue of 15 November

Film

"Taken: Natalee Holloway": Is the Series About the Case America Followed for Nearly Two Decades Worth Watching?

Netflix has released a documentary series about the disappearance of an American high school student in Aruba in 2005. In it, her mother and friends recount their long search for the truth and their struggle against the inaction of the local authorities.

"Taken: Natalee Holloway": Is the Series About the Case America Followed for Nearly Two Decades Worth Watching?
Photo: COURTESY OF NETFLIX, decider.com

The streaming service Netflix has released Taken: Natalee Holloway, a three-part documentary. Director Dani Sloane tells the story of the American high school student who vanished in Aruba in 2005, where she had traveled with her class after graduation. The story is narrated by the young woman's mother, Beth Holloway, by her friends and by Aruban residents who helped the family search for her.

The film sets out to show Natalee Holloway not merely as a victim whose portrait the whole country knew, but as a person. According to her mother and friends, Natalee was a bright, diligent student who loved spending time with her friends, though her studies always came first. On the trip to Aruba, she was seen in the company of Joran van der Sloot, who introduced himself as a tourist. On the night of May 30, 2005, she disappeared.

The first episode focuses on how slowly the Aruban police responded to what was happening. In particular, it captures Beth Holloway's frustration that van der Sloot and two brothers who had been in the car with him that night went so long without being detained. For the first time in 20 years, the series features the voice of Gerold Dompig, the country's deputy police chief. In an audio-only interview, he defends his department's actions. He explains, for instance, the arrest of hotel security guards whom van der Sloot had initially implicated, claiming they had helped Natalee into the hotel. That account later proved false.

For those who have followed the case over 21 years, the series is unlikely to reveal anything new. It has long been known that van der Sloot was the prime suspect in Holloway's disappearance and murder. Although he was later convicted of a similar killing in Peru, he admitted his guilt in the Holloway case only in 2023, once he was certain he no longer faced prosecution for it.

The film's value, however, lies in showing every twist of the case through the eyes of the people closest to Natalee. Her mother's participation is central. Beth Holloway spent weeks and months in Aruba trying to find out what had happened to her daughter. She gave interview after interview and held press conferences to keep Natalee's name in the news. Even today, her account carries her frustration with the local police and her anger at how van der Sloot evaded answering for years.

The film ends with footage of Beth Holloway standing with a journalist at the gates of van der Sloot's parents' house. "There has to be something," she says now, recalling that moment and suggesting they were hiding something.

Letters

You sign in with Telegram, and it takes a few seconds.

TVs, projectors and sound on the Union board

395,956ads posted on the Union board

Browse ads

More from Union Post